Distinguishing E-Money Services from Traditional Banking

Distinguishing E-Money Services from Traditional Banking

Regulatory Overview

  • E-Money Institutions (EMIs):
  • Regulated only by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK.
  • Cannot engage in traditional banking activities such as lending or offering 0verdrafts.
  • Focus on payment services, e-money issuance, and holding funds securely for clients.
  • Fully Regulated Banks:
  • Regulated by both the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) and the FCA.
  • Can provide a broader range of services, including lending, savings accounts, and overdrafts.
  • Subject to stricter capital and risk management requirements due to their ability to lend money.

Do You Need Help with Setting up a Bank Account?

We have the expertise to give you the advice that you need to make smart choices.

Get in touch and see what we can do for you.

Contact us

Photo of two smiling men, the one on the right is weating a lanyard and holding a copy of an Oury Clark guide to video games tax relief

Key Differences Between E-Money Institutions and Banks

Feature Lending E-Money Institution Not allowed to lend money. Fully Regulated Bank Allowed to lend money, but this carries risk (e.g., as seen with Silicon Valley Bank).
Feature Deposits E-Money Institution Holds client money securely but cannot use it for lending or investment Fully Regulated Bank Can use deposits for lending or investment, increasing risk exposure.
Feature Regulation E-Money Institution FCA-regulated only Fully Regulated Bank Dual-regulated by FCA and PRA.
Feature Guarantees E-Money Institution Funds held with EMIs are often backed by a Tier 1 lender (e.g., Barclays). Fully Regulated Bank Funds held with EMIs are often backed by a Tier 1 lender (e.g., Barclays).
Feature Revenue Model E-Money Institution Primarily earns through fees (e.g., foreign exchange, transactions). Fully Regulated Bank Earns revenue through lending and other financial products.
Feature Visa Sponsorship E-Money Institution Not accepted for UK sponsorship visas. Fully Regulated Bank Required for UK sponsorship visas.

Strengths and Weaknesses – E-Money Institutions

Strengths:

  • Safer for client funds as they cannot be used for risky lending or investments.
  • Funds are often guaranteed by Tier 1 banks (e.g., Barclays), ensuring additional security.
  • Efficient for international transfers, foreign exchange, and holding funds temporarily.

Weaknesses:

  • Cannot lend money or provide credit services.
  • Limited to basic payment services and holding client funds.
  • Not suitable for businesses needing full banking services or sponsorship visa requirements.

Strengths and Weaknesses – Fully Regulated Banks

Strengths:

  • Ability to lend money and provide comprehensive financial services.
  • Offers FSCS protection up to £85,000 per account.
  • Suitable for businesses needing full banking services, such as loans and sponsorship visas.

Weaknesses:

  • Riskier due to lending and investment activities (e.g., Silicon Valley Bank’s collapse).
  • Beyond the FSCS limit, deposits are not guaranteed, which can expose clients to potential losses.

Practical Considerations

  • Security: While e-money institutions hold funds securely (often backed by major banks), they do not offer FSCS protection. For amounts above £85,000, neither option fully guarantees your funds.
  • Risk: Banks inherently carry more risk because they lend and invest, while EMIs are limited to safeguarding client money.
  • Visa Sponsorship: Businesses requiring sponsorship visas must use a fully regulated bank, as e-money institutions are not recognized for this purpose in the UK.
  • Efficiency: E-money institutions are often more efficient for payments, transfers, and foreign exchange, but may lack the breadth of services provided by banks.

Conclusion

The choice between an e-money institution and a fully regulated bank depends on your needs:

  • For secure, simple payment services or holding funds temporarily, e-money institutions are a great option.
  • For businesses needing loans, credit services, or sponsorship visas, a fully regulated bank is essential.

Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of both options ensure sure that you can make informed financial decisions tailored to your business.

Let us Introduce Ourselves

To find your nearest office or get in touch with one of our specialist advisors to see how we can help your business, please go to our contact page.

Contact us